ACL Tear: Symptoms and Diagnosis

An anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tear is a common knee injury to the ligament that steadies the joint and stops the shin bone sliding forward. This guide explains the symptoms and causes of an ACL tear, how it is diagnosed and what treatment options exist.

Note: If you felt a pop in the knee at the time of injury followed by fast swelling or being unable to bear weight, see an orthopedic surgeon. Diagnosis needs an in-person examination.

Symptoms of an ACL tear

Symptoms of a tear may include the following, and they can resemble other knee injuries:

  • A pop heard or felt at the time of injury
  • Fast swelling of the knee within hours
  • Severe pain that stops you playing on
  • A feeling that the knee is unstable or gives way
  • Difficulty straightening or bending the knee
  • Difficulty putting weight on the leg

How does an ACL tear happen?

The injury usually happens during a sudden movement, most often from:

  • Changing direction quickly while running
  • Landing badly after a jump
  • Stopping suddenly
  • Twisting the knee with the foot planted
  • A direct blow in contact sports
  • Falls or road accidents

How is an ACL tear diagnosed?

Diagnosis starts with how the injury happened, followed by an examination in which the doctor tests the knee's stability by hand. An X-ray rules out fractures, and an MRI is usually requested to confirm the tear and show related injuries such as a meniscus tear. A tear cannot be confirmed without an in-person examination.

Treatment options

Non-surgical treatment

Not every patient needs surgery. The decision depends on age, activity level, sport, how stable the knee is and any other injuries in the joint.

  • Rest and activity changes at first
  • Cold packs wrapped in cloth and elevation to ease swelling
  • Physiotherapy to restore movement and strengthen the muscles
  • A knee brace when needed
  • Avoiding twisting and pivoting sports if the knee stays unstable

Surgical treatment

If the knee stays unstable, or the patient is an athlete who needs a stable joint, the surgeon may recommend arthroscopic ACL reconstruction. Related injuries are often treated during the same operation.

Recovery and rehabilitation

Rehabilitation is essential whether treatment is non-surgical or surgical. Recovery time varies from person to person and is set by the surgeon after assessment. See knee rehabilitation and returning to sport.

  1. Controlling pain and swelling
  2. Restoring knee range of motion
  3. Strengthening the thigh and leg muscles
  4. Balance and movement-control exercises
  5. A gradual return to activity

When to see the doctor

See an orthopedic surgeon promptly if:

  • You heard or felt a pop at the time of injury
  • The knee swelled quickly
  • You cannot stand or bear weight
  • The knee feels unstable or gives way
  • The knee locks and will not straighten
  • You notice numbness or a change in the colour of the foot

Frequently asked questions

Does an ACL heal on its own?

A complete tear does not usually heal with rest alone. Some patients, however, stay suitably active without surgery through rehabilitation, and the doctor decides this after assessment.

Does everyone with an ACL tear need an operation?

No. The decision depends on knee stability, your activity and sport, and other injuries in the joint. Your surgeon will discuss the options with you.

What should I do right after the injury?

Stop playing, apply a cold pack wrapped in cloth, raise the leg and avoid putting weight on it. Then see a doctor to have it assessed.

Can a tear be confirmed by examination alone?

An examination may point to a tear, but an MRI is usually requested to confirm it and to show related injuries.

Is it harmful to delay treatment?

An unstable knee can lead to further cartilage injury over time, so early assessment is advised.

Book your appointment

The clinic of Dr. Emeel Hourani in Amman, Ibn Khaldoun Street (Al-Khalidi Street), Panorama Hattar Building No. 22, 3rd floor.

Phone: +962 6 562 2482WhatsApp: +962 79 658 5724